I think some of you are underestimating how deranged these people can be. This won't end with Kirsche and Phase. There are people out there who believe Shiori Novella is a "TERF" because she said she liked a J.K. Rowling novel - do any of the volunteers share this opinion? Would any of them schizo out at her fans because of it? Who knows!
Remember, SJWs are not principled people, and as such the kinds of things they take issue with to a point of feeling justified engaging in life ruination over can change drastically overnight. Combine those with the vtuber community's general tendency to let defamatory rrats fly free, and you're in an environment where everyone, regardless of their political views or associations, should be especially careful who they trust - and therefore it's good practice and a show of good faith for people involved in hosting events to only seek access to sensitive information on a need-to-know basis. If they start asking for more than the bare minimum about me, I'd need a very, very good reason why I should trust them.
I wish I had a pessimistic reaction for posts like this. As I said, what it ultimately comes down to is how willing you are to believe that paranoia surrrounding the ID checking is justified. As far as anybody left of center is concerned, they're more than happy that they're handing over their IDs to protect from le evil scalpers, diregarding any thoughts that they might end up being the target of a deranged psycho progressive because they already have "the correct opinion".
I know around here we've had to deal with a lot of deranged lefties in our experiences here, and I don't disagree that there are a lot more of them around in the VTubing community (as well as in con leadership circles in general, not just offkai). But I do feel our perspective is skewed a bit by our biases towards expecting everybody to hate us - and anybody like us - as well as being heavily attatched to the concept of the slippery slope. It almost feels like people here (and most VTuber fans far enough right) have developed a persecution complex when a lot of people genuinely do not care about the kinds of people you watch and are more than happy to take your money regardless. Not only that, but I will reiterate that Phase Connect have OffKai management pretty firmly under their thumb at this point. If one or even a handful of losers try to do what you guys are describing, punishment is more than likely to be enacted against them.
On the other side, however, I do think the people blindly accepting that this is just the way it is are falling into their own fallacy of sunk cost. There
is reason to be paranoid, far more than most of these people are willing to accept. People in OffKai staff like Nyaru have been trying to quell fears about any kind of potential guest sabotage on the side of the volunteers, but she (like the other staff and the capipicord twats) are sticking their heads in the sand because they think they're free from anybody trying to hurt them over petty issues like this. It is absolutely within the realm of possibility that the convention may have somebody working there who's zealous enough to try and pull off a stunt like that. If OffKai
really wanted to offset fears they would put out a statement that anybody who does something like that will be severely punished, but I highly doubt that will happen.
Regardless, it's not on me that people are attending anyway. They've made their own decision that the good outweighs the bad and won't back down because some (from their perspective) über right wingers tell them they're gonna get doxxed, harassed and shunned. They do not think that will happen to them regardless of what we say.
On a personal note, this would likely get me to cancel my ticket had I gotten one, if not for living far enough away that getting one would be financially stupid of me. If I wanna see VTuber events (even in Cali alone) Anime Expo and their like are far more comfortable to be at relative to amateur acts like OffKai. We could
really use a way better VTuber-focused convention, and I'd like to see it sooner than later.