This also applies to Kiki consuming actual CP. Or even attempting to groom someone underage. A child doesn't need to be raped, here. She's not even requesting twerking videos.
Josh is right in that clip, but this ain't it.
That's the problem, here. The one thing that'll prove which side is right is something we have no way whatsoever to verify, and all we have to go on is the word of mouth from parties that are all very, very mentally ill. So all we can go off is what they do, not what they say. Everything Kiki has done demonstrates that she manifests her degenerate behavior within. If she had been abused as a child, then started going on and on about how much she wants shotas or whatever then yes, that would be the reddest flag and I don't think anyone would be arguing with you. It's the fact that it only seems to be manifesting as her having an extreme ageplay fetish--meaning her desires are being pointed inward and not outward--and the fact that there's not even an a hint that she's made any attempt on anyone underage.
The crux of the matter is the only thing that can affirm either side of this argument is something we'll likely never know. If she doesn't have CP on her hard drive, there's still hope for her with some therapy and possible medication. If she does, she's crossed the rubicon.
This issue is being muddied by the fact that not only is this a contentious and emotional issue, but there are people here that are very clearly latching it on to larger culture war issues that are only fueling the fire.
Speaking of fueling the fire, I would caution anyone from trying to cross-pollinate with this forum and that KF thread. You're not gonna convince anyone on the farms of anything, and you're just more likely to bring trouble here.