Out here telling it like it is.Gumpai having another melty it seems.
Out here telling it like it is.Gumpai having another melty it seems.
Gumpai having another melty it seems.
Gumpai having another melty it seems.
How many of them were openly admitting to being minors from the get go? Sexualizing minors is a lot more acceptable in Japan and not as taboo as it is in the West, so there's a very distinct cultural difference in that regard. While vtubing originated in Japan, I think its fair to say some cultural norms just don't belong. For example, the whole Japanese corpo norm of "accept your abuse, keep your head down" collectivism doesn't work in the West. We saw first hand how the West were furious with the Selen shitshow while a lot of Japanese fans didn't give a fuck. Some of them were even upset that Selen fought back against their attempt to destroy her career.Japanese corporations see no issue hiring minors for either the idol or vtuber industry. A whole ton of vtubers started streaming as minors. It's one of the most common 'admissions' I've heard behind the scenes in the industry. Is your oshi currently early 20's? Yeah, she was probably already streaming at 16 or 17 and already applying to corporations by then. I don't like it at all, but it's totally normalised within the industry. Hell, nobody ever bothered asking me what age I was when I started joining random IRC chats nearly 20 years ago, or how old I was when I was playing online D&D 15 years ago. I know we like to rag on places like AkioAIR for openly stating they hired a minor and acting like it wasn't an issue... but that's because it really wasn't (within the industry). They just underestimated how hard the backlash against admitting it publicly to the international market would be.
Gura was probably still in middle school when she started putting out content as BrownBeeTV, but those were premade videos not featuring her as a person.So for the other part, could a child make for genuinely entertaining content?
That shit isn't much worse than the western child pageants that used to be accepted and popular enough to have multiple tv shows made about them that ran for several years. Even after that shit got canceled, the exploitation just moved to youtube and their only attempt to stop it was to turn off comments on content with kids in it so people couldn't see all the nasty things people were saying. Tiktok is bad about this as well. All of it is the same type of shit with a different name.It's normal in Japan because sexualising minors in general is normal in Japan. They have junior idols modelling swimsuits in magazines for grown men, they have thirteen-year-olds in idol groups wearing the same skimpy outfits as the twenty-year-olds in music videos that get played on TV. They have enough plausible deniability to get away with it because they're marketing them as "cute" rather than "hot", but we can all see what's happening, and it's grossly exploitative.
Citing the backlash is completely ignoring the fact that that song and video was and continues to be one of her most popular songs. Not to mention she obviously had a very successful career after that before she even turned 18, so it should be pretty obvious that the general public didn't have any issue with her continued sexualization.When Britney Spears was in that music video wearing a "sexy schoolgirl" outfit at 16 it got a lot of backlash with some media outlets at the time straight-up comparing it to child pornography, even in countries like the UK where she'd have been of legal age - but it'd be business as normal over there, even with girls who're considerably younger. As an open idolfag it's something that makes me really uncomfortable, because there is literally no way an underage girl can fully understand the implications of putting themselves out there like that. It feels like the production companies are exploiting a loophole in the age of consent to make it happen; "we can't let people fuck them, but we can still profit from people wanting to fuck them".
Well that's the favored route. When I see people complain about the hypocrisy of not letting minors in the streaming space because a lot of us were crossing that boundary as kids and playing adult only content like GTA as pre-teens, the difference is the anonymity. When a minor admits to being a minor online, they are putting up a neon sign that attracts the groomers. A lot of us were told growing up about "you're going to get molested" as parents heard horror stories of groomers setting up an IRL meet with their mark and "To Catch a Predator" was scaring a lot of parents. We're also seeing a bell curve of online anonymity relative to age as old folks give out all this info because they don't know better, some (but not all) millenials that grew up with the internet learned to keep certain info private, and now the younger generations are just putting it all out there because social media has been there since day 1 for them.if its a child they can very easily just never tell anyone and it would make sense for safety reasons, many vtubers already use vtubing for some of the anonymity
That's not to say there weren't predators online back in the day (there definitely was) but it has certainly become more prominent and widespread. Part of this is because of the troon outbreak and the result of the exponential math of "the groomed become groomers" but it's also because they've realized how many kids are left unattended online with no supervision.
Well it's also because of the social media aspect in general and the consolidation of the internet. 20 years ago, the internet community was split up across numerous small ponds and people didn't come across the dark reality of the internet because it just didn't happen in their pond. Predators would have to hop around ponds to find their prey. Now that the web is consolidated, everyone is in one big lake and the kids are drawing more attention to the fact that they're kids.Trooners are definitely a portion of it, but they're not the sole bad actors. They're just the most visible because a large majority of them exist in a social bubble that demands attention and recognition, everything they do has to be visible to everyone because if they don't get validation then their lives mean nothing. Along with that, the amount of groomers and predators hasn't actually changed, we're just further along now with this technology becoming more integrated into the world, tech literacy is generally a more broad concept (but nowhere near what it needs to be) and we've all seen and heard more and more cases of these things happening that give a much more solid foundation to the knowledge that, yes, if you let teenagers have unrestricted and unmonitored access to the internet someone is going to try to fuck them. We're catching these things happening more both because it's more accessible and more people know the general basics even if they don't really observe safety, as the average person has become more complacent and content to simply sit on their hands and let their opinions be handed to them by the media they consume rather than have any agency of their own.
Well i was mostly speaking less around the scenario of a kid doing Vtubing by themselves and more of how more corporate or managed kids channels often have horror stories of the parent jewing out the kid out of revenue, i forgot how many times it has happened but i do recall a couple stories out there in the grapevine about shit like thatWell that's the favored route. When I see people complain about the hypocrisy of not letting minors in the streaming space because a lot of us were crossing that boundary as kids and playing adult only content like GTA as pre-teens, the difference is the anonymity. When a minor admits to being a minor online, they are putting up a neon sign that attracts the groomers. A lot of us were told growing up about "you're going to get molested" as parents heard horror stories of groomers setting up an IRL meet with their mark and "To Catch a Predator" was scaring a lot of parents. We're also seeing a bell curve of online anonymity relative to age as old folks give out all this info because they don't know better, some (but not all) millenials that grew up with the internet learned to keep certain info private, and now the younger generations are just putting it all out there because social media has been there since day 1 for them.
so it should be pretty obvious that the general public didn't have any issue with her continued sexualization.
You youngins who didn't have Armageddon during their lifetime'So Proctor, why exactly do you hope for Armageddon in your lifetime?' - people who don't know.
Don't forget about Haachama's former genmate Hitomi Chris. I think she was underage as well. If so, her story is an example of why minors shouldn't be vtubers.Shion and Haachama started as children and they're perfectly normal
She's still younger than a lot of the JP members, but some of the EN members are close to her age, or not much older. Laplus is younger than her, if I'm not mistaken. Some of the DEV_IS members might be younger than her as well.I wonder how long Haachama's going to stick with it. She's definitely one of the youngest in Hololive and also the most creative but also seems to have ongoing health problems.