My argument has always been I don't speak Japanese, so it takes a much worse VA to stick out as low quality in Japanese than English.Do not try to argue with the "SUBS > DUBS" crowd, they've been virtue signaling about what language they watch their Japanese cartoons in decades before politics got into English dubbing.
Just pat them on the head, tell them they're a very good weeb, and move on.
Of course she latched onto cookie.