Guys, I think we found one of the worst takes I've ever seen about Anime.
Just click on the Twitter thread. Everywhere you look this guy is just putting out more and more bad takes and he's just getting clowned on.
"Yeah but I'm poooor"Kaneko Lumi
-
🔓 Momosuzu Nene has returned from hiatus and explained her house was broken into and vandalized. 🔓
🎤 vHoeShow has announced debut times for their new JP wave. 🎤
🥜 God's Strongest Orc Vtuber, Randon, has put out an urgent call for assistance. 🥜
🕎 Idol Corp's Yena Youngblood has managed to delete her own Youtube channel (it has been recovered). 🕎 -
I'm in the market for an alternative server host. Please see here for details.
The Anime Thread
- Thread starter Realticule
- Start date
Guys, I think we found one of the worst takes I've ever seen about Anime.
Dude can't read emotions from low emotive characters. Most of his big rant is him asking to see the emotions/what the characters feel, when it is there just not as blatant as it tends to be in most shows.
I really liked this anime, how very foolish of me. Thanks this guy for setting me straight and telling me how I shouldn't like it.
On another note, I looked up aniwave just to see if there happened to be anything new and aniwave.SE came up. I didn't try to log in, but it's an exact copy of the real site except a bit shittier (just numbers and no titles for the episodes for example). Found it odd that commenters there were acting like nothing happened while people are still posting Fs in chat on the official subreddit. Just more bullshit fakery.
I'm mostly liking HiAnime except for the subs. At first it seemed great that you can customise the font and all kinds of style options, but I've found the actual translations to be pretty bad sometimes, and the worst thing is they'll have unimportant background text like shop signs or background conversations mixed up right there in the same lines as the main subs. Absolute lunacy
On another note, I looked up aniwave just to see if there happened to be anything new and aniwave.SE came up. I didn't try to log in, but it's an exact copy of the real site except a bit shittier (just numbers and no titles for the episodes for example). Found it odd that commenters there were acting like nothing happened while people are still posting Fs in chat on the official subreddit. Just more bullshit fakery.
I'm mostly liking HiAnime except for the subs. At first it seemed great that you can customise the font and all kinds of style options, but I've found the actual translations to be pretty bad sometimes, and the worst thing is they'll have unimportant background text like shop signs or background conversations mixed up right there in the same lines as the main subs. Absolute lunacy
EverythingMoe - Index of best Anime/Manga sites
Curated toplist of everything Otaku culture. Up to date list of best anime/manga websites and apps with detailed reviews, pros, and cons for each.
You can check the sites listed here to see which works best for you. Personally I just went back to torrenting.
Oho? What's this? Another LN review 40 trillion years later? Nani the fu- okay I'll fucking stop.
It is me, John Light Novel, your cellmate who diddles your ass at night between reading sessions, coming in for one more round of literary buttfucking (no homo). I wanted to write a review about that one LN with the old dude with the peg leg but I got bored half-way through and then lost my draft so fuck that we doing something else. If you read the last review then you know the drill, I am not reading the fucking manga... ya-da ya-da, let's get on with it.
Today we are witness to:
The Conqueror from a Dying Kingdom (Horobi no Kuni no Seifukusha)
Volumes Read:
Up to Volume 7 (Latest published volume at the time of writing)
Original run:
April 5th, 2020 – Present (Complete publishing re-write, original webnovel still ongoing? I think?)
Author:
Fudeorca
Genre:
Isekai (Political & Historical Fiction, High Fantasy/No Magic, Kingdom Building, Academy, No RPG elements, Wartime Fiction)
Positives
65/100 Better than most.
I am way too self-concious about these reviews nobody will read... see you in 200 years I guess
Edit: bruh rat gives me autistic winner 5 seconds after I post it, motherfucker you didn't even read it!
Previous Reviews:
Ascendance of a Bookworm
It is me, John Light Novel, your cellmate who diddles your ass at night between reading sessions, coming in for one more round of literary buttfucking (no homo). I wanted to write a review about that one LN with the old dude with the peg leg but I got bored half-way through and then lost my draft so fuck that we doing something else. If you read the last review then you know the drill, I am not reading the fucking manga... ya-da ya-da, let's get on with it.
Today we are witness to:
The Conqueror from a Dying Kingdom (Horobi no Kuni no Seifukusha)
Volumes Read:
Up to Volume 7 (Latest published volume at the time of writing)
Original run:
April 5th, 2020 – Present (Complete publishing re-write, original webnovel still ongoing? I think?)
Author:
Fudeorca
Genre:
Isekai (Political & Historical Fiction, High Fantasy/No Magic, Kingdom Building, Academy, No RPG elements, Wartime Fiction)
Conqueror (as I will refer to it from now on) is the story of Yuri, a dude who dies and get reincarnated in another world (wow how original), what conqueror does to set itself apart is make Yuri a persecuted minority, I am not joking.
Yuri is a member of the Shanti people, a weird elf-like race of humans who are different to regular humans (Kulati) and who have been politically and religiously persecuted and genocided for hundreds of years as of the beginning of the story. Mostly because they are an easy and weak common enemy for all of mankind and there are many political and economic incentives to killing or enslaving all of them.
Yuri is then basically forced to stand up for his people and fight against the coming extermination, the book is a pretty straight forward story which only gathers tension as Yuri (rather suddenly) grows up and then has to assume more and more responsibilities and protect more and more people, the sacrifices he's forced to make and the lives he's forced to take as the tension ramps up make the latter volumes the undisputed best of the series.
Yuri is a member of the Shanti people, a weird elf-like race of humans who are different to regular humans (Kulati) and who have been politically and religiously persecuted and genocided for hundreds of years as of the beginning of the story. Mostly because they are an easy and weak common enemy for all of mankind and there are many political and economic incentives to killing or enslaving all of them.
Yuri is then basically forced to stand up for his people and fight against the coming extermination, the book is a pretty straight forward story which only gathers tension as Yuri (rather suddenly) grows up and then has to assume more and more responsibilities and protect more and more people, the sacrifices he's forced to make and the lives he's forced to take as the tension ramps up make the latter volumes the undisputed best of the series.
The story takes place in an alternate version of earth in the Scandinavian peninsula which is now called the Kingdom of Shiyalta, now Shiyalta in itself isn't really that different from any other generic setting in isekai and that is where my complaints with conqueror mainly lie.
The thing with conqueror is that it doesn't excel in any particular ways with its worldbuilding (or any other aspect of its writing). For one, there's no magic (which may count as a positive or a negative depending on how you look at it), there are some fantastical creatures like dragons or giant eagles but most of the story revolves around normal humans in a late-medieval time period, only with alternative history and cultures. There is very little "fantasy" to the world of conqueror and while it does detract from the awe-factor the book might've had, grounding it in realism opens new doors for storytelling.
What conqueror does well is go one or two extra steps further than most isekai, it puts in just that small additional amount of work that makes it stand out from its contemporaries. The cultures of the Shanti and Kulati are certainly the most developed parts of its world, specially the Shanti who are quite unique, while the Kulati more conventionally mimic and remix cultures from our own world.
The Shanti are a matriarcal society, which is quite the rarity in isekai. Their socio-political organization with matriarch-led families, the so called "witches", leading the government and patriarch-led chieftain families leading the country's armies, their strange relationship with their bird mounts and their long and complex history are probably the standout points of conqueror's worldbuilding. The politics and social divides of the world between the Shanti and Kulati are interesting and take cues from our own world, but there being two different species of human adds and extra edge not seen when talking about humans vs humans or totally alien creatures vs humans. We often get isekai stories where a racial conflict is looked upon from the perspective of the humans, because we are humans and that's a logical thing to do, but viewing the world from the perspective of a persecuted people trapped at their last stand is thrilling and really cements the war with the Kulati as an inevitable, looming threat.
The future of the world and how finally reversing the tide of Kulati conquest will change the politics of different countries has me hungry for the next volume, conqueror's worldbuilding only becomes more interesting and intricate as it goes on, and while it doesn't do anything particularly crazy with it, it doesn't do anything particularly wrong either (except maybe some uninspired character and place names) so it gets a pass from me.
The thing with conqueror is that it doesn't excel in any particular ways with its worldbuilding (or any other aspect of its writing). For one, there's no magic (which may count as a positive or a negative depending on how you look at it), there are some fantastical creatures like dragons or giant eagles but most of the story revolves around normal humans in a late-medieval time period, only with alternative history and cultures. There is very little "fantasy" to the world of conqueror and while it does detract from the awe-factor the book might've had, grounding it in realism opens new doors for storytelling.
What conqueror does well is go one or two extra steps further than most isekai, it puts in just that small additional amount of work that makes it stand out from its contemporaries. The cultures of the Shanti and Kulati are certainly the most developed parts of its world, specially the Shanti who are quite unique, while the Kulati more conventionally mimic and remix cultures from our own world.
The Shanti are a matriarcal society, which is quite the rarity in isekai. Their socio-political organization with matriarch-led families, the so called "witches", leading the government and patriarch-led chieftain families leading the country's armies, their strange relationship with their bird mounts and their long and complex history are probably the standout points of conqueror's worldbuilding. The politics and social divides of the world between the Shanti and Kulati are interesting and take cues from our own world, but there being two different species of human adds and extra edge not seen when talking about humans vs humans or totally alien creatures vs humans. We often get isekai stories where a racial conflict is looked upon from the perspective of the humans, because we are humans and that's a logical thing to do, but viewing the world from the perspective of a persecuted people trapped at their last stand is thrilling and really cements the war with the Kulati as an inevitable, looming threat.
The future of the world and how finally reversing the tide of Kulati conquest will change the politics of different countries has me hungry for the next volume, conqueror's worldbuilding only becomes more interesting and intricate as it goes on, and while it doesn't do anything particularly crazy with it, it doesn't do anything particularly wrong either (except maybe some uninspired character and place names) so it gets a pass from me.
Protagonist:
Our protagonist is Yuri Ho, an Isekai'd wagie who gets reborn in this world to a chieftain family, the Ho clan. And there's no easy to say this... Yuri is probably the worst character in the whole story.
Yuri is very much one of the proto-typical, goodie-two-shoes, highly intelligent, always confident, always handsome male leads which infest isekai. What does work to try to set him apart are two core aspects. For starters, Yuri is very driven towards a defined goal, i.e. not getting genocided, this keeps him from being incredibly passive and only acting when the story forces him to, Yuri consistently tries to do things which further his goals and he takes initiative to achieve what he wants, he's not just some laid back idiot being taken along for the ride.
The second point is that Yuri is not completely moral and always good like many other isekai leads. This ties in with a larger theme in conqueror about death: Yuri kills people, many people, he does horrible and reprehensible things for understandable reasons but he's never completely in the right, you can look at his actions and disagree with them and see him as morally gray. Killing his enemies holds more weight than just slashing away at hordes of mobs for Xp, each kill matters and is never played as "totally justified" like in many other stories. Sometimes Yuri kills because he has no other option, sometimes he does it because keeping his enemy alive will ruin his plans in the future and sometimes he does it out of pure selfishness and rage.
All of this praise, however, does not keep Yuri from being kind of bland for a lot of the story (specially the early volumes), he's confident about all of his choices, he always has a plan, he excels at pretty much everything he does, he doesn't have overpowered abilities (and this does get used a couple of times to actually introduce some vulnerability to his character) but he always seems to be two steps ahead of his enemies due to his previous life knowledge. Yuri rarely ever looks vulnerable and whenever he does it's only because other people around him are placed in danger, if Yuri didn't love anyone and didn't have attachments for his enemies to exploit then he'd basically become invincible.
Yuri is very much a product of the Rudeus brand of leads, just strutting around and owning the place for most of the story while sometimes fucking up and having a big cry moment, the only thing he has over his forefathers is not being so passive (one of my biggest gripes with Rudeus).
All in all: Not terrible but also not the best (which ironically places him in the top 1% of isekai leads lol).
Main characters:
Conqueror's mains are a mixed bag of greatness and forgettable nonsense.
Some characters, like Mylo and Carol, are fucking great. Carol starts off as an annoying asshole but she becomes a lot more relatable and likeable as time goes on. And Mylo is simply my personal favorite character in the whole thing.
But apart from those two there's really not that much to look forward to. Yuri's dad is cool but forgettable, his gaggle of love interests are all so forgettable that I can't even remember their names. People in the castle, the company and the academy all kind of blend together because they just don't really matter.
One of the worst offenders though has to be Yuri's cousin (who is also in love with him for whatever fucking reason) and she exemplifies a huge issue I have with conqueror's handling of characters: Timeskips.
For whatever twisted reason Fudeorca loves using huge timeskips where several months or years go by and the characters age up so other stuff can happen. But these also function as a sneaky way for him to basically go "Oh the characters have known each other for yeaaaaars now so they're good friends!" which I really do not like. Character development does not work like this, you can't just establish Yuri meeting someone, then boom timeskip, then he suddenly gets along with them. This happens with Yuri's academy roommates who both hate his guts and then are suddenly friends with him, his cousin which he starts to bond with in an interesting scene and then boom timeskip, oh they already bonded years ago, and one of the antagonists who while somewhat telegraphed that she was gonna become antagonistic the story also expects you to subconsciously add a bunch of more "in-between" time skipped scenes that the writer was too lazy to do so that her eventual betrayal makes sense!
Antagonists and Minor characters:
In my opinion, Conqueror's greatest characters can be found in its supplementary cast and antagonists. It's just that their potential hasn't been fully tapped yet.
The few characters we get to know in the Kulati side, who are as oblivious to the Shanti as we are to them, have this uniquely mysterious vibe. Some of them are sympathetic characters which are obviously going to play a much greater role in future, others are despicable villains that have more depth than just a cursory glance can reveal.
Of course, enemies do not just exist in the enemy nations, forces within Shiyalta itself pose formidable threats, but their buildup as villains is somewhat mishandled in my opinion, even if their ends are my favorite part of the series so far.
All-in-all conqueror doesn't have too many characters, but a lot of them play such meaningless roles and appear so little that you will forget about them anyway. Definitely not the author's strong suit.
Our protagonist is Yuri Ho, an Isekai'd wagie who gets reborn in this world to a chieftain family, the Ho clan. And there's no easy to say this... Yuri is probably the worst character in the whole story.
Yuri is very much one of the proto-typical, goodie-two-shoes, highly intelligent, always confident, always handsome male leads which infest isekai. What does work to try to set him apart are two core aspects. For starters, Yuri is very driven towards a defined goal, i.e. not getting genocided, this keeps him from being incredibly passive and only acting when the story forces him to, Yuri consistently tries to do things which further his goals and he takes initiative to achieve what he wants, he's not just some laid back idiot being taken along for the ride.
The second point is that Yuri is not completely moral and always good like many other isekai leads. This ties in with a larger theme in conqueror about death: Yuri kills people, many people, he does horrible and reprehensible things for understandable reasons but he's never completely in the right, you can look at his actions and disagree with them and see him as morally gray. Killing his enemies holds more weight than just slashing away at hordes of mobs for Xp, each kill matters and is never played as "totally justified" like in many other stories. Sometimes Yuri kills because he has no other option, sometimes he does it because keeping his enemy alive will ruin his plans in the future and sometimes he does it out of pure selfishness and rage.
All of this praise, however, does not keep Yuri from being kind of bland for a lot of the story (specially the early volumes), he's confident about all of his choices, he always has a plan, he excels at pretty much everything he does, he doesn't have overpowered abilities (and this does get used a couple of times to actually introduce some vulnerability to his character) but he always seems to be two steps ahead of his enemies due to his previous life knowledge. Yuri rarely ever looks vulnerable and whenever he does it's only because other people around him are placed in danger, if Yuri didn't love anyone and didn't have attachments for his enemies to exploit then he'd basically become invincible.
Yuri is very much a product of the Rudeus brand of leads, just strutting around and owning the place for most of the story while sometimes fucking up and having a big cry moment, the only thing he has over his forefathers is not being so passive (one of my biggest gripes with Rudeus).
All in all: Not terrible but also not the best (which ironically places him in the top 1% of isekai leads lol).
Main characters:
Conqueror's mains are a mixed bag of greatness and forgettable nonsense.
Some characters, like Mylo and Carol, are fucking great. Carol starts off as an annoying asshole but she becomes a lot more relatable and likeable as time goes on. And Mylo is simply my personal favorite character in the whole thing.
But apart from those two there's really not that much to look forward to. Yuri's dad is cool but forgettable, his gaggle of love interests are all so forgettable that I can't even remember their names. People in the castle, the company and the academy all kind of blend together because they just don't really matter.
One of the worst offenders though has to be Yuri's cousin (who is also in love with him for whatever fucking reason) and she exemplifies a huge issue I have with conqueror's handling of characters: Timeskips.
For whatever twisted reason Fudeorca loves using huge timeskips where several months or years go by and the characters age up so other stuff can happen. But these also function as a sneaky way for him to basically go "Oh the characters have known each other for yeaaaaars now so they're good friends!" which I really do not like. Character development does not work like this, you can't just establish Yuri meeting someone, then boom timeskip, then he suddenly gets along with them. This happens with Yuri's academy roommates who both hate his guts and then are suddenly friends with him, his cousin which he starts to bond with in an interesting scene and then boom timeskip, oh they already bonded years ago, and one of the antagonists who while somewhat telegraphed that she was gonna become antagonistic the story also expects you to subconsciously add a bunch of more "in-between" time skipped scenes that the writer was too lazy to do so that her eventual betrayal makes sense!
Antagonists and Minor characters:
In my opinion, Conqueror's greatest characters can be found in its supplementary cast and antagonists. It's just that their potential hasn't been fully tapped yet.
The few characters we get to know in the Kulati side, who are as oblivious to the Shanti as we are to them, have this uniquely mysterious vibe. Some of them are sympathetic characters which are obviously going to play a much greater role in future, others are despicable villains that have more depth than just a cursory glance can reveal.
Of course, enemies do not just exist in the enemy nations, forces within Shiyalta itself pose formidable threats, but their buildup as villains is somewhat mishandled in my opinion, even if their ends are my favorite part of the series so far.
All-in-all conqueror doesn't have too many characters, but a lot of them play such meaningless roles and appear so little that you will forget about them anyway. Definitely not the author's strong suit.
Conqueror's pacing (as discussed in the characters section) is its biggest issue overall, the constant timeskips and seemingly unfinished story beats as the story jumps forwards to the next setpiece are jarring and make the first 3 or so volumes less than stellar reading experiences. The beginning of the first volume is downright boring, I couldn't care less about Yuri's pre-isekai life which barely affects his character afterwards. The first chapters seem in a rush to age Yuri up so the author can do the things they want to do and get to the storylines they want to tell, but the way it is handled is awkward and ends up being more confusing than anything. At least I didn't care much for it.
This issue keeps churning while Yuri still has growing to do up to about the 5th volume, when Yuri is essentially an adult and the story slows down to a much more enjoyable wartime narrative. Before that the whole thing just feels like this anthology of disconnected events and stories which sort-of build on top of each other but make the story VERY floaty.
The style of conqueror is standard for isekai, the language used fits with the time period and the characters speak like they're supposed to in relation to their personalities and backgrounds. A good thing about having no magic is that conqueror has absolutely no destructive plot devices, no powerleveling, no nonsense of any kind. The story could honestly be re-worked to not even be an isekai and it would work just as well.
The tone sort of fluctuates between lighthearted isekai adventure and serious political drama for the first few volumes, though it isn't as jarring as it sounds and it stays mostly consistent, it certainly doesn't cheapen out suspenseful moments for a quick laugh. In the latter half the series quite masterfully transitions into a much darker and much more serious tone, things are bleak and the characters are forced to make tough choices as everything crumbles around them and the extermination only looms closer.
The themes are, without a doubt, conqueror's best aspect. As briefly touched upon before, conqueror is a wartime story, and death is treated as a very serious and very real consequence. Many of the kills in the series, specially those executed by Yuri himself, are described in great detail to denote their brutality and the impact of taking a life. People aren't just killed off with a quick laugh, dispatched emotionlessly because they aren't friends with the MC and therefore are irredeemably evil; people die in brutal fashion and their deaths aren't pretty, the characters don't cheer when killing because it isn't a fun or happy thing to do.
Conqueror explores topics of religious ideology, racial persecution, cold-hearted politics and the desperation of those who know they have no escape from eradication The Shanti aren't treated as poor little victims, they were once powerful and cruel and when their power waned, they were used as a escape goat for the other countries to maintain peace over a shared enemy. There's no morals shoved down your throat, simply the circumstances which created the status quo and which would've been normal in such a world and society. It is clearly pointed out that the Shanti squabbled amongst themselves, refused to adapt to new technologies or reach out to outside countries and have a corrupt, rotting political system which makes it impossible for them to ever fight back.
There's a great deal of opportunity in future storylines for this series in regards to how Yuri's actions will affect the status quo, and those are probably the most exciting prospects for the series as a whole.
This issue keeps churning while Yuri still has growing to do up to about the 5th volume, when Yuri is essentially an adult and the story slows down to a much more enjoyable wartime narrative. Before that the whole thing just feels like this anthology of disconnected events and stories which sort-of build on top of each other but make the story VERY floaty.
The style of conqueror is standard for isekai, the language used fits with the time period and the characters speak like they're supposed to in relation to their personalities and backgrounds. A good thing about having no magic is that conqueror has absolutely no destructive plot devices, no powerleveling, no nonsense of any kind. The story could honestly be re-worked to not even be an isekai and it would work just as well.
The tone sort of fluctuates between lighthearted isekai adventure and serious political drama for the first few volumes, though it isn't as jarring as it sounds and it stays mostly consistent, it certainly doesn't cheapen out suspenseful moments for a quick laugh. In the latter half the series quite masterfully transitions into a much darker and much more serious tone, things are bleak and the characters are forced to make tough choices as everything crumbles around them and the extermination only looms closer.
The themes are, without a doubt, conqueror's best aspect. As briefly touched upon before, conqueror is a wartime story, and death is treated as a very serious and very real consequence. Many of the kills in the series, specially those executed by Yuri himself, are described in great detail to denote their brutality and the impact of taking a life. People aren't just killed off with a quick laugh, dispatched emotionlessly because they aren't friends with the MC and therefore are irredeemably evil; people die in brutal fashion and their deaths aren't pretty, the characters don't cheer when killing because it isn't a fun or happy thing to do.
Conqueror explores topics of religious ideology, racial persecution, cold-hearted politics and the desperation of those who know they have no escape from eradication The Shanti aren't treated as poor little victims, they were once powerful and cruel and when their power waned, they were used as a escape goat for the other countries to maintain peace over a shared enemy. There's no morals shoved down your throat, simply the circumstances which created the status quo and which would've been normal in such a world and society. It is clearly pointed out that the Shanti squabbled amongst themselves, refused to adapt to new technologies or reach out to outside countries and have a corrupt, rotting political system which makes it impossible for them to ever fight back.
There's a great deal of opportunity in future storylines for this series in regards to how Yuri's actions will affect the status quo, and those are probably the most exciting prospects for the series as a whole.
Conqueror is a fine series for what it is, with average characters, a somewhat generic world and yet tons of potential for a great and engaging story going forward. While it may have been no better than any of its contemporaries at first, once the main narrative engine gets going the book can be quite a fascinating read. It doesn't commit any particularly egregious literally sins and it does most things better than other isekai (which isn't saying a lot).
Overall a fine read if you like isekai.
Overall a fine read if you like isekai.
Positives
- Interesting and unique setting
- Engaging narrative (in the latter half)
- Great wartime story
- Doesn't rely on cheap, contrived plot devices or other narrative cancer, solidly written
- Isekai which is done with some semblance of competency
- Pacing is all over the place (in the first half)
- So-so characters, generic lead
- Boring start, lackluster first few volumes
65/100 Better than most.
I am way too self-concious about these reviews nobody will read... see you in 200 years I guess
Edit: bruh rat gives me autistic winner 5 seconds after I post it, motherfucker you didn't even read it!
Previous Reviews:
Ascendance of a Bookworm
Worldbuilding (Competent magic system if any, interesting world, general uniqueness/innovation, emphasis on culture/economy/politics/history/religion, memorable locations, creative creature/race concepts)
30%
Characters (Interesting/memorable character concepts/interactions, competent characterization, competent character arcs, relatable/likeable protagonist who experiences changes and growth, competent/likeable supporting cast, competent antagonist(s)
30%
Pacing, Style, Tone & Themes (Consistent and appropriate pacing, location/time period appropriate writing style/character dialogue, consistent and appropriate tone for the story, interesting themes, No narrative cancer/plotholes/contrivance)
30%
How much I enjoyed it personally
10%
What the rankings mean:
96-100 Unreachable, this ranking will never be awarded
91-95 Excellent, with no flaws
81-90 Excellent, with some small flaws
71-80 Good, with a couple of significant flaws
61-70 Good, but filled with potential to be better
51-60 Mediocre, with a path to redemption
41-50 Mediocre, with no way to save it
31-40 Bad, but still has its moments
21-30 Bad, barely tolerable slop
11-20 Trash, painful to read
1-10 Trash, Didn't bother to finish it
0 Scourge on literature which fills me with anguish
30%
Characters (Interesting/memorable character concepts/interactions, competent characterization, competent character arcs, relatable/likeable protagonist who experiences changes and growth, competent/likeable supporting cast, competent antagonist(s)
30%
Pacing, Style, Tone & Themes (Consistent and appropriate pacing, location/time period appropriate writing style/character dialogue, consistent and appropriate tone for the story, interesting themes, No narrative cancer/plotholes/contrivance)
30%
How much I enjoyed it personally
10%
What the rankings mean:
96-100 Unreachable, this ranking will never be awarded
91-95 Excellent, with no flaws
81-90 Excellent, with some small flaws
71-80 Good, with a couple of significant flaws
61-70 Good, but filled with potential to be better
51-60 Mediocre, with a path to redemption
41-50 Mediocre, with no way to save it
31-40 Bad, but still has its moments
21-30 Bad, barely tolerable slop
11-20 Trash, painful to read
1-10 Trash, Didn't bother to finish it
0 Scourge on literature which fills me with anguish
Last edited:
Dandadan's first episode is out. I was grinning from ear to ear the entire time. The first episode was literally a perfect adaptation. If it keeps up the quality it's an easy shoe in for AOTY and potentially one of the best in the last handfull of years.
Holy fucking shit.
5 years and only 4 episodes btw. Also apparently the director of the Tower of God anime which was panned for its animation "quality" also directed this episode.
Holy fucking shit.
Don't know if this is true or not but
Last edited:
Oh my god, did they hire animators from Queen Bee?Don't know if this is true or not but
Pretty meh season for new anime this season besides the sequels and remakes which is fine for me, more time to watch vtubers I guess. Someone already mentioned Dandadan, the only legit promising one. There are a few more airing in the next few days, but so far..
Orb: On the Movements of the Earth - Story is set in historical Poland where the Church is inquisition-ing heretics, some kid genius who was supposed to be studying theology but is instead doing science-y things like the theory that the Earth orbits the Sun. A kid getting tortured was not on my bingo card for this season..
Ranma 1/2 2024 remake - Very faithful remake of the original anime, they even got almost all the original JP voice actors back to reprise their old roles. Tis comfort food for 90s anime fans .
Kenshin Remake season 2 - Similar to Ranma, but they've finally gotten to the good season aka the Kyoto Arc. First season was kinda boring setup, finally we get to the fights, hope this remake does them justice.
The Stories of Girls Who Couldn't Be Magicians - Wants to be Little Witch Academia but without the creativity or charm. Plot is boilerplate magic academy shenanigan only redeeming quality is the pretty pastel art style that looks like a kids story book.
Orb: On the Movements of the Earth - Story is set in historical Poland where the Church is inquisition-ing heretics, some kid genius who was supposed to be studying theology but is instead doing science-y things like the theory that the Earth orbits the Sun. A kid getting tortured was not on my bingo card for this season..
Ranma 1/2 2024 remake - Very faithful remake of the original anime, they even got almost all the original JP voice actors back to reprise their old roles. Tis comfort food for 90s anime fans .
Kenshin Remake season 2 - Similar to Ranma, but they've finally gotten to the good season aka the Kyoto Arc. First season was kinda boring setup, finally we get to the fights, hope this remake does them justice.
The Stories of Girls Who Couldn't Be Magicians - Wants to be Little Witch Academia but without the creativity or charm. Plot is boilerplate magic academy shenanigan only redeeming quality is the pretty pastel art style that looks like a kids story book.
I'm starting to think Junji Ito might be as cursed as Berserk is to never get a good looking full adaptation.
Edit: Holy shit.
I'm starting to think Junji Ito might be as cursed as Berserk is to never get a good looking full adaptation.
Edit: Holy shit.
Bruh. She wasn't even moving. It looked like she just broke her neck randomly while having a seizure on the stairs lmao.
Last edited:
Stuff I'm watching this season:
MF Ghost Season 2
Thoroughly enjoyed the first season so this is a no brainer. More racing and eurobeat in the mix? Yes please.
Trillion Game
Two friends bullshitting their way to become trillionaires. I already read a bit of the manga but the anime really exemplifies how over the top this series is
I can fix him Let's make each other worse.
Dandadan
What else needs to be said?
Pretty good season for me because I barely watched anything last season.
Rurouni Kenshin: Meiji Kenkaku Romantan - Kyoto Douran
The best arc heck even one of the best arcs in shonen anime as whole. I'm really hoping they manage to do the fights here justice especially the Kenshin vs Aoshi battle.MF Ghost Season 2
Thoroughly enjoyed the first season so this is a no brainer. More racing and eurobeat in the mix? Yes please.
Thunderbolt Fantasy: Touriken Yuuki 4
Season 4 of kino puppetry. Bless fansubbers because CR has yet to announce this in their simulcast lineup.Ranma 1/2 Remake
Really enjoyed the remake of Urusei Yatsura so this is an instant pickup.Trillion Game
Two friends bullshitting their way to become trillionaires. I already read a bit of the manga but the anime really exemplifies how over the top this series is
Tsuma, Shougakusei ni Naru.
I'll admit the premise of this series is pretty questionable but curiosity got the best of me. It was a real good move of them to release 2 episodes from the get-go because episode 2 sets the tone of this series going forward and is looking to be a real tearjerker of a series.Raise wa Tanin ga Ii
Dandadan
What else needs to be said?
Pretty good season for me because I barely watched anything last season.
The Horror isn't Junji Ito the Horror is the animation.
I'm starting to think Junji Ito might be as cursed as Berserk is to never get a good looking full adaptation.
Edit: Holy shit.
As someone who never saw Ito's works outside of people resposting art on twitter back in the day this is how I will forever view his work. Amazing, 10/10, maximum Neil Breen action
His stuff is great. Especially his autobiography of himself and his cat done is his usual horrifying art style. I highly recommend you check out some of his anthologies or something like Gyo, Uzumaki, or Hellstar Remina.
Similar threads
- Locked
