"Stop with anymore requests of seeing real body pieces and go watch a twitch whore instead leave me the fuck alone you make me uncomfortable at this point"Tenma Maemi

General Thread v3: The Hexagone

Status
Not open for further replies.

Abomination

The abominable amalgamation known as "chyaaat!"
Joined:  Apr 1, 2023

Sankisei

HOLOLIVE SAIKYO
Joined:  Feb 23, 2023
A twitter callout post over a well-known fanartist:


It made me remember this, because it's pretty much exactly what he seems to be doing:

Either way though, posting to official art tags and having no disclaimers is a dick move since talents could get in trouble (legal trouble, not to mention twitter seethe) for not knowing and using it for thumbnails.


Yeah about using that art....
 

Titanosaurus

Well-known member
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 12, 2022
A twitter callout post over a well-known fanartist:


It made me remember this, because it's pretty much exactly what he seems to be doing:

Either way though, posting to official art tags and having no disclaimers is a dick move since talents could get in trouble (legal trouble, not to mention twitter seethe) for not knowing and using it for thumbnails.

"I don't think that's fair to real artists who otherwise would have gotten some attention"
Just wait till there's 1 AI program that can generate art and post in a Vtuber's chat and make stupid twitter comments. Just hogging up all that sweet attention!
AI-Kun you're so funny! You get a 🔧 :Vesper-UNHINGED:
 

Hff201

Pippa Fan, Failed Normalfriend
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 13, 2022
A twitter callout post over a well-known fanartist:


It made me remember this, because it's pretty much exactly what he seems to be doing:

Either way though, posting to official art tags and having no disclaimers is a dick move since talents could get in trouble (legal trouble, not to mention twitter seethe) for not knowing and using it for thumbnails.

Regardless of how people feel about this right now, this will be standard practice in 10-15 years, if not sooner. Artists using shortcuts to help with more monotonous and/or difficult parts of drawing has been a thing for as long as digital art has been around, with plenty of people including industry professionals making use of filters, texture packs, stock backgrounds etc. in their work. Generative AI is another such tool, and while I can understand the legal concern in this particular instance since that hasn't exactly been figured out yet and it would be genuinely unfair for vtubers and/or agencies to get into trouble over such a trivial infraction, there's really no moral argument to be made.

If we take this piece as an example:

Untitled.jpg

There's no denying the body and blazer have obviously been lifted from the AI base - but when comparing the complete pieces, there's enough difference between them that it feels like the artist had a vision of what he wanted to create and used the AI generation as a middle step in his workflow to help him achieve that, rather than just cynically pushing out slop. It's not plagiarism in the same way tracing a human artist's illustration would be since this base doesn't explicitly belong to anyone, and reworking it into the Bae picture with a new pattern on the skirt, new colour grading, added subtle grain etc. is all creative input on his part.

I'd be genuinely interested to see how the first eventual lawsuit over something like this plays out, because someone would have to notice part of their own work that's somehow remained recognisable after both the AI mashing together the millions of source material from the boorus and being painted over by the new artist, and be able to prove demonstrable damages that have arisen from this happening. Anything that isn't a very obvious "[AI work] has directly lifted [Plaintiff's Illustration]" is going to feel like opportunists being opportunists just trying their luck, like the recent lawsuit from Marvin Gaye's estate against Ed Sheeran, since Thinking Out Loud apparently sounds like Let's Get It On.
 

Punished Anime Discusser

Well-known member
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 12, 2022
It is the second to last day of 2024.
Mentally unwell AIbros, and insufferably homosexual anti-AIfags have to have one last contest over who is the most insufferable group of retards on social media, when in reality they both deserve total AI-spergery-adjacent death.
 

TwoBit

Well-known member
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 10, 2022
A twitter callout post over a well-known fanartist:


It made me remember this, because it's pretty much exactly what he seems to be doing:

Either way though, posting to official art tags and having no disclaimers is a dick move since talents could get in trouble (legal trouble, not to mention twitter seethe) for not knowing and using it for thumbnails.

Have I just become boomer brained when it comes to identifying AI images or do you really need to have a knack for seeing AI in anime pictures? The finger thing was the only one I could see because AI always sucks when it comes to creating hands and fingers.
 

Smelliest007

I left Kson
Joined:  Feb 19, 2024
Have I just become boomer brained when it comes to identifying AI images or do you really need to have a knack for seeing AI in anime pictures? The finger thing was the only one I could see because AI always sucks when it comes to creating hands and fingers.
I can never tell either.
 

agility_

We have some serious streams to discuss 🔨
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 14, 2022
Have I just become boomer brained when it comes to identifying AI images or do you really need to have a knack for seeing AI in anime pictures? The finger thing was the only one I could see because AI always sucks when it comes to creating hands and fingers.
AI-slop is easy enough given how plentiful and derivative it is. It's when the proomptbros somehow manage to generate a stylized version of someone's art that's the tricky part. Most of the time though it's the same horeshit "asian-looking dollface with huge boobs".
 

I Wanna Die

Don't do drugs, blow all your money on vtubers
Joined:  Nov 15, 2023
It has begun. Are you ready to get even more parasocial with your oshi?
 

El Rrata

Gringo Tolerable
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 9, 2022

Yeah about using that art....

She been using Jygfams' art for years. She also follows and retweets his art consistently, which is very rare for her to do for any art.
 

NeneHATE

Spectral Nene
Early Adopter
Nene's Pet Latinx
Latinx/Latine
Joined:  Sep 16, 2022
She been using Jygfams' art for years. She also follows and retweets his art consistently, which is very rare for her to do for any art.
Ratking be like IT SHOULDVE BEEN ME! NOT HIM!
 

thhrang

Punished Autism Extraordinaire
Early Adopter
Ward Security
♥Realticule's Husbando♥
Joined:  Sep 13, 2022

El Rrata

Gringo Tolerable
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 9, 2022

agility_

We have some serious streams to discuss 🔨
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 14, 2022


"I'm very sensitive to noise"
"I'll take showers at 3 am"
"I'll cook full meals at am"

Well Ina, round and round we go, running away from stress and not adapting. Or, we could try and become someone new and maybe just learn something about ourselves.
 

JMForte

Well-known member
Joined:  Oct 1, 2022
Lia did a member stream and was being particularly menhera.
 

Negzana

Well-known member
Joined:  Apr 15, 2023
I've been mostly ignoring the date for the past month and now I realize there's only 5 days until Fauna's graduation, fuck.

Lia did a member stream and was being particularly menhera.
I heard it and it was really hard to listen to it because she really sounded demoralized. Too much shit happened this year, that part really got to me. Phase has become the only survivor of all the initial waves of vtubing boom small corpos in the West, and it must be sad to see all your competing small corpos collapsing within just a few months. I hope she can find the drive to continue because I want to see her succeed and be happy. She did good this year, shouldn't let herself down.
 

Titanosaurus

Well-known member
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 12, 2022

Negzana

Well-known member
Joined:  Apr 15, 2023

tl;dr

She seems to not like the image she made for herself (I assume she means degenerate tumblr zoomer with questionable world knowledge?) but is trapped between either continuing it and further getting punished by youtube strikes, or not doing it and her numbers crashing and fans growing disinterested.

She has had many projects frozen or cancelled due to a mix of management being too slow to communicate or her worrying it won't be good enough and just freezing it

She was also demoralized by the rapid succession of small corpo closures this year, which she felt helped Phase in its first years stay lean and efficient due to actual competition. Now they're all gone, and Phase is doing good but now they're peerless in the industry and have nobody to really keep them on their toes. She is also just sad to see all these corpos and people she grew to see part of the vtubing ecosystem just die so rapidly.
 

Titanosaurus

Well-known member
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 12, 2022
tl;dr

She seems to not like the image she made for herself (I assume she means degenerate tumblr zoomer with questionable world knowledge?) but is trapped between either continuing it and further getting punished by youtube strikes, or not doing it and her numbers crashing and fans growing disinterested.

She has had many projects frozen or cancelled due to a mix of management being too slow to communicate or her worrying it won't be good enough and just freezing it

She was also demoralized by the rapid succession of small corpo closures this year, which she felt helped Phase in its first years stay lean and efficient due to actual competition. Now they're all gone, and Phase is doing good but now they're peerless in the industry and have nobody to really keep them on their toes. She is also just sad to see all these corpos and people she grew to see part of the vtubing ecosystem just die so rapidly.
Maybe she's outgrowing tumblr humor. Could be for the best, I do think she over uses some of those bits and it gets repetitive. I mean, she has to have changed over 3-4 years.
 

JusticeDog

Well-known member
Joined:  Jul 3, 2024
A twitter callout post over a well-known fanartist:


It made me remember this, because it's pretty much exactly what he seems to be doing:

Either way though, posting to official art tags and having no disclaimers is a dick move since talents could get in trouble (legal trouble, not to mention twitter seethe) for not knowing and using it for thumbnails.

How are people stupid enough not to notice it's AI when that guy is posting new art every other day.

:ponrys:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom