"So you're an enemy?"Tokino Sora

HoloAdvent En3 Talent Discussion/Debut Thread

lalilulelo

Well-known member
Joined:  Jul 10, 2023
if i recall correctly, no one predicted the holocouncil girls correctly until debut. this is probably gonna be the same case.

i dont know how everyone predicted the holomyth and all of the tempus boys correctly. i think the only one they didnt predict from tempus was lando and lloyd
 

Titanosaurus

Well-known member
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 12, 2022

God's Strongest Dragoon

Well-known member
Joined:  Mar 20, 2023
if i recall correctly, no one predicted the holocouncil girls correctly until debut. this is probably gonna be the same case.

i dont know how everyone predicted the holomyth and all of the tempus boys correctly. i think the only one they didnt predict from tempus was lando and lloyd
Lando was predicted. I'm pretty sure like one or two of the council girls were predicted before the debut, I specifically recall Fauna being predicted to be Lemonleaf really early on. I think it was the twitter interactions that caused people to guess Fauna pre-debut. I'm not 100% sure on what exactly did it but I think Shondo's behavior tipped a lot of people off.
 

DaddyChill

What the hell is even that!
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 11, 2022
All I gotta say is
Lore.. LOL
:NOWWELAUGH:
 

Stunned But Dumb

Well-known member
Joined:  Jan 29, 2023
Concerning the earlier theory, that someone who made it in was canned when the twins applied, leading to a previous model being shelved and a twin model of an existing one being made.

Would never happen. Unless you fuck up, if you're in, you're in.

However, Holo does typically open auditions for five member generations, and it's safe to say that they didn't start the audition process with twins in mind. Models also have plenty of precedent of predating the talents (may or may not be tweaked after the talent has been picked).

So the possibility that a model was shelved to make space for the twins is actually a pretty strong one.

But shelving a model is such a waste... what if a sixth talent did make it in? Just not as part of this gen, but as, say, vsinger #2?

Absolutely a rrat, but I've seen crazier things.

There's that rumor that Kiara was supposed to be gen 5 before being moved to HoloEn. Perhaps that "sixth" talent is being saved for later
 

reinigen

Dang it
Ward Security
Joined:  Sep 16, 2022
if i recall correctly, no one predicted the holocouncil girls correctly until debut. this is probably gonna be the same case.

Lando was predicted. I'm pretty sure like one or two of the council girls were predicted before the debut, I specifically recall Fauna being predicted to be Lemonleaf really early on. I think it was the twitter interactions that caused people to guess Fauna pre-debut. I'm not 100% sure on what exactly did it but I think Shondo's behavior tipped a lot of people off.
Kronii was pegged for her previous VTuber persona Seru, a seal vtuber, pretty fast due to a friend releasing a Kronii fanart 12 minutes after their debut trailer. The Dottovu connection wasn't made til after her debut.

And while it wasn't known that Sana was Namie, they did figure she was part of the group based on the promo art she drew.

As @Jambalaya said, Fauna also was figured out due to Shondo having a Woman Moment™ on Twitter and vague posting enough people made the connection.

I believe Mumei and Bae were unknown, but Shachimu was a favorite candidate going in so people pegged her right away. I remember Bae being Marica took the longest to source.
 

Thomas Talus

Εκ λόγου άλλος εκβαίνει λόγος
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 15, 2022
I believe Mumei and Bae were unknown, but Shachimu was a favorite candidate going in so people pegged her right away. I remember Bae being Marica took the longest to source.
IIRC Marica was considered a possibility fairly early, although not confirmed until much later.
 

Nenélove

Chief Commissar of Holochistan
Early Adopter
Nene's Pet Latinx
Latinx/Latine
Joined:  Sep 16, 2022
Kronii was pegged for her previous VTuber persona Seru, a seal vtuber, pretty fast due to a friend releasing a Kronii fanart 12 minutes after their debut trailer. The Dottovu connection wasn't made til after her debut.

And while it wasn't known that Sana was Namie, they did figure she was part of the group based on the promo art she drew.

As @Jambalaya said, Fauna also was figured out due to Shondo having a Woman Moment™ on Twitter and vague posting enough people made the connection.

I believe Mumei and Bae were unknown, but Shachimu was a favorite candidate going in so people pegged her right away. I remember Bae being Marica took the longest to source.
Correct, I remember it being like this too. Marica was also a suspect but around that time there were so many possible candidates we just didn't know. Most of these candidates ended up in Niji or Idol btw.
 

Scoots

The Pontiff of PonWolf
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 10, 2022
For those who care, shamelessly stolen from reddit:
View attachment 37786
New shortest and new tallest
Thanos is pleased

That's the one
View attachment 37811View attachment 37812

Designed by Lui's and Chloe's artists, respectively, they were unveiled in 2nd Fes and auditions were held for the characters, which I believe is when Chloe and Lui were hired (Lui mentioned having to wait a year to debut), but never ended up being used. Though, obviously, both artists were retained and asked to design the girls that became Lui and Chloe.
You know looking at those models they have similarities to Lui and Chloe what with the bird motif for proto Lui and the black/white/red color scheme for Chloe I can see both talents using those respective models
i dont know how everyone predicted the holomyth and all of the tempus boys correctly. i think the only one they didnt predict from tempus was lando and lloyd
Lando was confirmed cause he magposted his art on VT and it was a dead ringer for his Lando style
Kronii was pegged for her previous VTuber persona Seru, a seal vtuber, pretty fast due to a friend releasing a Kronii fanart 12 minutes after their debut trailer. The Dottovu connection wasn't made til after her debut.

And while it wasn't known that Sana was Namie, they did figure she was part of the group based on the promo art she drew.

As @Jambalaya said, Fauna also was figured out due to Shondo having a Woman Moment™ on Twitter and vague posting enough people made the connection.

I believe Mumei and Bae were unknown, but Shachimu was a favorite candidate going in so people pegged her right away. I remember Bae being Marica took the longest to source.
Shachimu was thought to be Petra in Obsydia and likely who Selen thought she was then Council happened and we were like "there she is"

And yeah I remember the magic Kronii art that was funny

I remember Bae being last as well but she was pegged during her debut iirc
 

God's Strongest Wardog

🫵👋🚛💥🌌☕
Joined:  Mar 20, 2023
not directly confirmed, no, but I have good enough reason to believe that the answer is "yes" (all of the evidence in their visuals, behavior, etc so far) - that being said, it's still speculation, just incredibly likely speculation

if it's NOT them, boy, the fallout is going to be something
If it's somehow not them, i'm gonna anti the shit out of whoever it is them :calidrinking:
Nah but seriously I just be bummed out a little, though happy they're still doing what they wanted in 2024 with their final idol venture.

If it was them though, I wonder if they left GGN cause they got picked up by Holo under a year ago or were just let go and they went searching for jobs elsewhere or uh Vtuber contracts or however the hell this shit works after.​
No, Mangagamer dumped them because they were retards. Their manager while working on the GGN channel was all kinds of pissed off, but literally couldn't do anything except act as go between the fans and the girls.

I'm sure she's the happiest that the girls are moving forward and up after what was tantamount to getting disposed of like garbage.

They got rate limited. :koronehappyl:
 
Last edited:

John Vtuber👁️

Sentient Eyeball, Primarch of Hag Pride Worldwide
Certified Manwhore
Joined:  Oct 24, 2022
No, Mangagamer dumped them because they were retards. Their manager while working on the GGN channel was all kinds of pissed off, but literally couldn't do anything except act as go between the fans and the girls.

I'm sure she's the happiest that the girls are moving forward and up after what was tantamount to getting disposed of like garbage.

I also have a bit of bad blood with MangaGamer and associates, but that was a lifetime ago. I feel like their financial troubles would have been vastly improved, if they stuck with the GGN branding and girls instead of chasing what they perceived to be the 'easy money'. Visual Novels in the west had their peak nearly a decade ago, they failed to capitalize on it, and as a result stick to selling pornography. Sure, when I was a strapping young lad, I was all about that, but then I grew up, got back into my religion, discarded pornographic interests - and it seems the overall market outside of MangaGamer is also slowly going the same way, with people craving the cult-classics they otherwise wouldn't have known existed with even a modicum of proper marketing and stream presence, but those aren't even on the table when coomers still keep their lights on, however dim its brightness over the years.

...But I digress, autism and personal anecdotes aside, I want nothing but the best for the twins. They were treated horribly, they deserve the success, I'm going to Tier 3 the second it drops and remain for as long as they wish to stay with HoloLive. I hope that they do, they have the sheer potential to make millions under the company just like the other top talents there.

Want a cult-hit VN that has been largely passed over because there is absolutely zero marketing presence or stream presence? This one's for the weebs, a remake of an early-2000's ADV that wears its inspirations on its sleeves, they do not make them like this anymore:

 

Horo7618

No one in particular
Joined:  Sep 12, 2022

Brosnan Pierce Brosnan

God's Strongest Smartass
Dizzy's Husband
Joined:  Apr 4, 2023

dragoonkain3

Member
Joined:  Feb 23, 2023
if i recall correctly, no one predicted the holocouncil girls correctly until debut. this is probably gonna be the same case.

i dont know how everyone predicted the holomyth and all of the tempus boys correctly. i think the only one they didnt predict from tempus was lando and lloyd
Lando was the ONLY 100% prediction of Tempus, as he liked a Magni art on his Lando account, but it was screenshotted by 3 other anons before he removed it. It was Axel who people couldn't identify until post debut, as he was a literal who. Can't comment on Vanguard, as I was out of town during the week of their debut.

As for council girls, the only one that was wrongly predicted by a lot of people was Fauna, who most people wanted to be Hana Flores (aka Beryl) but this may have been copium more than anything (Lemonleaf was the 2nd most popular guess). Kronii was like a 90% guess as her Dottovu friends had a Kronii fan art twit like a few minutes after her twitter came up, Sana was about the same prediction strength as we knew that she was connected to Ina, while Mumei was about a 70% prediction strength as her art was VERY similar to Shachimu (plus Shachimu was the highest subbed youtuber that was available at that time AND she didn't become NijiEN's Petra). I forgot exactly how Bae got deduced, but I'm 100% sure the name Marica Bellrose came up before debut and was the lead guess (if I had to guess, it's because Miori was one of the first followers).

IRyS was the hilarious one, as the first guess most people had in vt was Avril Lavigne. Probably just a meme joke, but after that Namirin was the the highest prediction due to being the highest profile anime singer with Vtubing experience, on top of living in Japan (which is probably a requirement due to recording issues and it was the height of Covid restictions).
 

Kazuma

I do be doobing
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 10, 2022
Lando was predicted. I'm pretty sure like one or two of the council girls were predicted before the debut, I specifically recall Fauna being predicted to be Lemonleaf really early on. I think it was the twitter interactions that caused people to guess Fauna pre-debut. I'm not 100% sure on what exactly did it but I think Shondo's behavior tipped a lot of people off.
I remember some people were saying Fauna was Hana Flores pre-Council debut.

Lando was the ONLY 100% prediction of Tempus, as he liked a Magni art on his Lando account, but it was screenshotted by 3 other anons before he removed it. It was Axel who people couldn't identify until post debut, as he was a literal who. Can't comment on Vanguard, as I was out of town during the week of their debut.

As for council girls, the only one that was wrongly predicted by a lot of people was Fauna, who most people wanted to be Hana Flores (aka Beryl) but this may have been copium more than anything (Lemonleaf was the 2nd most popular guess). Kronii was like a 90% guess as her Dottovu friends had a Kronii fan art twit like a few minutes after her twitter came up, Sana was about the same prediction strength as we knew that she was connected to Ina, while Mumei was about a 70% prediction strength as her art was VERY similar to Shachimu (plus Shachimu was the highest subbed youtuber that was available at that time AND she didn't become NijiEN's Petra). I forgot exactly how Bae got deduced, but I'm 100% sure the name Marica Bellrose came up before debut and was the lead guess (if I had to guess, it's because Miori was one of the first followers).

IRyS was the hilarious one, as the first guess most people had in vt was Avril Lavigne. Probably just a meme joke, but after that Namirin was the the highest prediction due to being the highest profile anime singer with Vtubing experience, on top of living in Japan (which is probably a requirement due to recording issues and it was the height of Covid restictions).
Also Nami had a pon moment where she replied to Calli's tweet with her Nami account.
 
Last edited:

BlueSharkTV

Fucking Riggers
Early Adopter
Yuria's Husband
Joined:  Sep 10, 2022
apparently nerissa liked this meme on twitter.
F19tyqPWAAEqHzr.jpg
and off course kronii's tards are already bitching about it. ARCHIVE
tard.jpg

can't wait for kronii to like/retweet the meme. :ironmousekek:
 

RiverBear

Well-known member
Joined:  Sep 29, 2022
if i recall correctly, no one predicted the holocouncil girls correctly until debut. this is probably gonna be the same case.
Speak for yourself

Dottovu/Kronii was a given because her artist friend (whose name I'm blanking on right now) posted a highly detailed fan art Kronii even before any of the official reveals.

Namie was also a given because of the art used in their official reveal.

People were also expecting Marica Bellerose in some capacity
 

Hff201

Pippa Fan, Failed Normalfriend
Early Adopter
Joined:  Sep 13, 2022
I did mention it is totally possible they pulled a Tempus and debuted more later. But them shelving designs is actually not without prescedence. They did it in the past, actually.

View attachment 37811View attachment 37812

Designed by Lui's and Chloe's artists, respectively, they were unveiled in 2nd Fes and auditions were held for the characters, which I believe is when Chloe and Lui were hired (Lui mentioned having to wait a year to debut), but never ended up being used. Though, obviously, both artists were retained and asked to design the girls that became Lui and Chloe.
I'm surprised they didn't keep auditions open for unused characters and integrate them into later generations or projects if they find someone fitting, it seems like a waste not to use them.

I really like the design on the right, even if she is just a more mature-looking Remi.
 

Sky Shouter

YEAH! TONIGHT!
Joined:  Sep 15, 2022
Shiori's artist has a talent for drawing captivating eyes




The kind of eyes that say "I'm not letting you pull out" and "If I see you talking to any female that isn't me very bad things will happen"
 

Horo7618

No one in particular
Joined:  Sep 12, 2022
Top Bottom