The Outer Worlds 1 was mediocre dogshit, however, it was put out at a time where anti-Bethesda sentiment was at it's absolute peak and people were so desperate for another title to be majorly succesful in the single-player Fallout-esque niche (especially from Obsidian) to spite them that they all collectively gaslit themselves into believing otherwise. It's honestly one of the weirdest collective bait-and-switch moments I've seen surrounding a game that then immediately evaporated from public consciousness just as soon as they didn't need to keep up the pretense.